by PedroR » Fri May 13, 2011 3:03 pm
by PedroR
Fri May 13, 2011 3:03 pm
Hi
We are still waiting for a response from Robotis about this (our commercial contacts with them are on a business trip).
In any case, the more I think about the current line up for DARwIn the more I'm inclined to believe the 6k DARwIn is some mis understanding of the reporter.
Otherwise you'd have:
- DARwIn OP Deluxe - the GA version at 12k, pre assembled and with 2 year extended warranty (covers manufacturing defects and other malfunctions although I don't know exactly what's the "extent" of "extended warranty").
- DARwInOP Academic Edition - for Universities and research only (who are customers that can do self maintenance), also pre assembled but with only 1 year warranty covering manufacturing defects only.
This is a bit cheaper than the Deluxe version but still costs well above 6k.
So how would you justify the discount for the 6k kit? It would be cheaper just because it's un assembled?
That would mean that, depending on the edition, Robotis would be charging 4k - 6k extra for the work of pre assembling and testing the kit (plus packing extended warranty and a few extras in the case of the Deluxe version)
Let it be clear that this is my _personal_ option, as we have no official information from Robotis. Just sharing my thoughts.
On the other hand, the article does mention something that is very true: the cost of these robots should be coming down over the next years. I don't expect it to come down as fast as cell phone prices do for example (the peak lifetime of a Humanoid kit spans over 3 years and slowly declines after that period).
Boards like IGEP are quite cheap and embedded TEGRA boards as well as lower cost Fit PC style computers are around the corner. This would enable lower cost alternatives but this is still an area for hackers and research.
I don't think other manufacturers have yet understood that embedded (Linux) is the direction to go (apart from Nao and Robotis).
It may take a while for them to get there and develop lower cost out-of-the-box Kits to compete in this market segment.
Pedro.
Hi
We are still waiting for a response from Robotis about this (our commercial contacts with them are on a business trip).
In any case, the more I think about the current line up for DARwIn the more I'm inclined to believe the 6k DARwIn is some mis understanding of the reporter.
Otherwise you'd have:
- DARwIn OP Deluxe - the GA version at 12k, pre assembled and with 2 year extended warranty (covers manufacturing defects and other malfunctions although I don't know exactly what's the "extent" of "extended warranty").
- DARwInOP Academic Edition - for Universities and research only (who are customers that can do self maintenance), also pre assembled but with only 1 year warranty covering manufacturing defects only.
This is a bit cheaper than the Deluxe version but still costs well above 6k.
So how would you justify the discount for the 6k kit? It would be cheaper just because it's un assembled?
That would mean that, depending on the edition, Robotis would be charging 4k - 6k extra for the work of pre assembling and testing the kit (plus packing extended warranty and a few extras in the case of the Deluxe version)
Let it be clear that this is my _personal_ option, as we have no official information from Robotis. Just sharing my thoughts.
On the other hand, the article does mention something that is very true: the cost of these robots should be coming down over the next years. I don't expect it to come down as fast as cell phone prices do for example (the peak lifetime of a Humanoid kit spans over 3 years and slowly declines after that period).
Boards like IGEP are quite cheap and embedded TEGRA boards as well as lower cost Fit PC style computers are around the corner. This would enable lower cost alternatives but this is still an area for hackers and research.
I don't think other manufacturers have yet understood that embedded (Linux) is the direction to go (apart from Nao and Robotis).
It may take a while for them to get there and develop lower cost out-of-the-box Kits to compete in this market segment.
Pedro.
Last edited by
PedroR on Thu Sep 08, 2011 10:40 am, edited 1 time in total.