RoboSavvy Forum

Building my own [first] robot

2007-11-20T19:45:18+01:00

srobot wrote:
If you want to do a lot with programming, I would go for the Bioloid and a GumStix.

I would probably go for that combination. I do want a lot of flexibility in making many types of applications. I also liked the ability to add Micro SD for internal storage, which might be useful for sensor-data logging and other functions.

Also, the problem is with time of shipment - it takes almost a month for anything to reach where I live (middle-east) and so, it's just better I decide on what I want and order it, then play with things gradually..

So, thanks a lot!

Statistics: Posted by aviad — Tue Nov 20, 2007 7:45 pm

Building my own [first] robot

2007-11-20T18:43:16+01:00

aviad wrote:
srobot wrote:
aviad wrote:Is it still recommended that I wait for the philo? Also, if I do, is it still recommended that I replace its controller with the gumstix board?

I would say no at the start. The only reason I'd go with a GumStix is if you need/want big programs on it. Or you need high power computing.

No for RoboPhilo or for the GumStix?

Oops!

No for GumStix. Although if you feel you need or want the power, get one! Remember, if you find that the stock controller does not do what you want, you can always get a GumStix latter.

If you want to do a lot with programming, I would go for the Bioloid and a GumStix.

--Scotty

Statistics: Posted by srobot — Tue Nov 20, 2007 6:43 pm

Building my own [first] robot

2007-11-20T18:16:29+01:00

srobot wrote:
aviad wrote:Is it still recommended that I wait for the philo? Also, if I do, is it still recommended that I replace its controller with the gumstix board?

I would say no at the start. The only reason I'd go with a GumStix is if you need/want big programs on it. Or you need high power computing.

No for RoboPhilo or for the GumStix?

Statistics: Posted by aviad — Tue Nov 20, 2007 6:16 pm

Building my own [first] robot

2007-11-20T17:48:14+01:00

aviad wrote:
The idea of stocking up on servos and brackets appealed to me at first but eventually I've decided to drop the idea for the time being since, like you said in the first paragraph I quoted, I will get lost in all the hardware mess.

It's not so bad if you stick to Lynxmotion brackets and compatible servos; they include all the hardware you need to connect them together, and it all goes pretty easily. The same goes for the Bioloid parts too. It's only when you start trying to build new parts from scratch that you run into those ornery hardware issues.

aviad wrote:
There will be some tinkering involved, eventually - I will want to modify the robot and make it my own. Is it still recommended that I wait for the philo?

Nobody has much experience with the philo yet, of course, but I think you probably could. Since it comes as a kit, and you assemble it, you should be able to disassemble and customize it as desired. It's also programmable, so you can start your AI experiments right away. And for only $400, even if you just learn general principles from it, it's probably money well spent.

Compare this to the i-Sobot, which is a great little robot and even cheaper ($300), but comes fully assembled, is not programmable, and does not encourage any hacking. (However, its motion and balance are superb, from what I've heard, so it would serve as great inspiration for your own work.)

Best,
— Joe

Statistics: Posted by Joe — Tue Nov 20, 2007 5:48 pm

Building my own [first] robot

2007-11-20T17:04:40+01:00

aviad wrote:
Is it still recommended that I wait for the philo? Also, if I do, is it still recommended that I replace its controller with the gumstix board?

I would say no at the start. The only reason I'd go with a GumStix is if you need/want big programs on it. Or you need high power computing.

Ok, so maybe also if you can't do what you want to do with the stock controller also...

With RoboPhilo, the sensors and motors connect directly to the board, unlike the the Bioloid which go through each other.

Here's a blog post I did on RoboPhilo:

http://ribolabs.wordpress.com/2007/10/2 ... ilo-cheap/

All the best,
--Scotty

Statistics: Posted by srobot — Tue Nov 20, 2007 5:04 pm

Building my own [first] robot

2007-11-20T06:23:24+01:00

Joe wrote:
To the original poster: I'm a programmer myself, and I'll warn you that the hardware side of things is much harder than it looks. Stupid things like finding a screw that fits into a given hole (or drilling and threading a hole to fit a screw!) will sometimes set you back for a week, at least if you're like me. Start small (or with a kit) and stock up on patience.

Instead of a full humanoid kit, another way to go is to gather Lynxmotion brackets and compatible servos. These let you do neat things like this with a much smaller investment, and also give you much greater freedom to make any sort of robot you want. (Though to be fair, the Bioloid kit gives you nearly the same freedom, and its servos are a much better value.)

The idea of stocking up on servos and brackets appealed to me at first but eventually I've decided to drop the idea for the time being since, like you said in the first paragraph I quoted, I will get lost in all the hardware mess. I've done some tinkering in the past but fixing an old router is probably not the same as building a robot.

Joe wrote:
sthmck wrote:I am wondering if you are only interested in getting a humanoid. If so then I would wait till the robophilo comes out, because it is a bit cheaper than the rest of these.

I think this is a good idea — and you won't have to wait long; I just got an email saying that they should be shipping in a couple of weeks. You can (and should) order it as a kit, so you both understand well how it is assembled, and don't feel bashful about taking it apart to fix or modify it.

There will be some tinkering involved, eventually - I will want to modify the robot and make it my own. Is it still recommended that I wait for the philo? Also, if I do, is it still recommended that I replace its controller with the gumstix board?

Statistics: Posted by aviad — Tue Nov 20, 2007 6:23 am

Building my own [first] robot

2007-11-20T06:09:09+01:00

sthmck wrote:
I am wondering if you are only interested in getting a humanoid. If so then I would wait till the robophilo comes out, because it is a bit cheaper than the rest of these.

I think this is a good idea — and you won't have to wait long; I just got an email saying that they should be shipping in a couple of weeks. You can (and should) order it as a kit, so you both understand well how it is assembled, and don't feel bashful about taking it apart to fix or modify it.

To the original poster: I'm a programmer myself, and I'll warn you that the hardware side of things is much harder than it looks. Stupid things like finding a screw that fits into a given hole (or drilling and threading a hole to fit a screw!) will sometimes set you back for a week, at least if you're like me. Start small (or with a kit) and stock up on patience.

Instead of a full humanoid kit, another way to go is to gather Lynxmotion brackets and compatible servos. These let you do neat things like this with a much smaller investment, and also give you much greater freedom to make any sort of robot you want. (Though to be fair, the Bioloid kit gives you nearly the same freedom, and its servos are a much better value.)

Best,
— Joe

Statistics: Posted by Joe — Tue Nov 20, 2007 6:09 am

Building my own [first] robot

2007-11-20T06:08:47+01:00

Joe wrote:
aviad wrote:The comparison is a lot of help! What I want to achieve is an autonomous robot - however, it seems that sometimes robots that are controlled via R/C are also referred to as "autonomous robots"...

No. "Autonomous" in robotics means not remote-controlled. Many robots can be either autonomous or remote controlled, but they're never both at the same time.

Okay - but orchestrated robots (robots that were programmed to perform a "show" and can do only that from start to end, maybe in a loop) are considered to be autonomous even though they have no intelligence driving them to do so?

On the other hand, you can call AI just that - a very elaborated choreography.. I'm just trying to figure the terminology I suppose.

Statistics: Posted by aviad — Tue Nov 20, 2007 6:08 am

Building my own [first] robot

2007-11-20T06:03:14+01:00

aviad wrote:
The comparison is a lot of help! What I want to achieve is an autonomous robot - however, it seems that sometimes robots that are controlled via R/C are also referred to as "autonomous robots"...

No. "Autonomous" in robotics means not remote-controlled. Many robots can be either autonomous or remote controlled, but they're never both at the same time.

(Well, OK, there is the gray area of semi-autonomous robots, that both take directions from their human controller but also make rapid tactical decisions on their own. But that's semi-autonomous; if a robot is referred to as autonomous, then it's not taking any remote control at all.)

Best,
— Joe

Statistics: Posted by Joe — Tue Nov 20, 2007 6:03 am

Building my own [first] robot

2007-11-19T18:27:39+01:00

aviad wrote:
srobot wrote:Because you say your a programmer, I'd say go with the Bioloid and get a GumStix controller.

Also, which flavor? It seems like there are three - and only the "extreme" allows for C programming.. However, it costs 4 times the normal one.. Is that what you meant, though?

Edit: Unless what you meant is actually to remove the original controller and add the GumStix one, which is inherently C programmable since it's a Linux machine?

Yes, swap out the CM-5 (stock controller board) for a GumStix.

If you look around in the Bioloid section of this forum you should be able to find some information on it.

All the best,
--Scotty

Statistics: Posted by srobot — Mon Nov 19, 2007 6:27 pm

Building my own [first] robot

2007-11-19T18:23:52+01:00

aviad wrote:
srobot wrote:What kind of programming language do you want?

I prefer a more structural language. If it was object-oriented I would be extremely pleased but I am no stranger to C and prefer it over most languages anyway.

You mean like EasyC?

http://flickr.com/photos/22974884@N00/428674505/

aviad wrote:
srobot wrote:Check out this comparison of Humanoids site:

http://robotservicesgroup.com/

What do you want your robot for, and to do?

The comparison is a lot of help! What I want to achieve is an autonomous robot - however, it seems that sometimes robots that are controlled via R/C are also referred to as "autonomous robots" - what I want is an experiment in AI combined with real sensory data.

Thanks for the help,
Aviad.

Thanks!

All of the humanoid kits on this forum start as true autonomous robots. Some people add remotes, some add sensors, some add servos, and some people add it all.

--Scotty

Statistics: Posted by srobot — Mon Nov 19, 2007 6:23 pm

Building my own [first] robot

2007-11-19T17:40:19+01:00

srobot wrote:
Because you say your a programmer, I'd say go with the Bioloid and get a GumStix controller.

Also, which flavor? It seems like there are three - and only the "extreme" allows for C programming.. However, it costs 4 times the normal one.. Is that what you meant, though?

Edit: Unless what you meant is actually to remove the original controller and add the GumStix one, which is inherently C programmable since it's a Linux machine?

Statistics: Posted by aviad — Mon Nov 19, 2007 5:40 pm

Building my own [first] robot

2007-11-19T17:32:46+01:00

srobot wrote:
What kind of programming language do you want?

I prefer a more structural language. If it was object-oriented I would be extremely pleased but I am no stranger to C and prefer it over most languages anyway.

srobot wrote:
Because you say your a programmer, I'd say go with the Bioloid and get a GumStix controller.

What is the GumStix controller? I know they have "very small computers" what's their controller product? Just one of the computers?

srobot wrote:
Check out this comparison of Humanoids site:

http://robotservicesgroup.com/

What do you want your robot for, and to do?

The comparison is a lot of help! What I want to achieve is an autonomous robot - however, it seems that sometimes robots that are controlled via R/C are also referred to as "autonomous robots" - what I want is an experiment in AI combined with real sensory data.

Thanks for the help,
Aviad.

Statistics: Posted by aviad — Mon Nov 19, 2007 5:32 pm

Building my own [first] robot

2007-11-19T16:19:02+01:00

aviad wrote:
bbrainmonkey wrote:As a start, I would buy a kit such as the Robonova and hack it.

From the information available, it seems that working with the Robonova is only through that RoboBasic language. Are there alternatives to it? Maybe replace its micro-controller?

Are there other starter kits, or maybe even some "shopping list" that one could get with a proper manual to help do things?

Right now I only know of RoboBasic for the RoboNova-1. Check out the "C programming for RoboNova" post.

What kind of programming language do you want?

Currently no "starter kits", or "shopping lists" are available for Humanoids that I know of.

Because you say your a programmer, I'd say go with the Bioloid and get a GumStix controller.

aviad wrote:
bbrainmonkey wrote:
As a start, I would buy a kit such as the Robonova and hack it.

Also, what are the benefits of the robonova? I mean, compared to other robot kits like Futaba or Bioloid?

Check out this comparison of Humanoids site:

http://robotservicesgroup.com/

What do you want your robot for, and to do?

Cheers,
--srobot

Statistics: Posted by srobot — Mon Nov 19, 2007 4:19 pm

Building my own [first] robot

2007-11-19T16:17:14+01:00

I am wondering if you are only interested in getting a humanoid. If so then I would wait till the robophilo comes out, because it is a bit cheaper than the rest of these. If you are looking to build something autonomous your best bet would be to start with something that uses wheels. the boe-bot will take you through basic concepts and the price isnt that bad. I am not a programmer (yet I am working on getting a degree) and working with this kit really helped me out a lot. Also the boe-bot has more room for sensors. You can put sensors on the humanoids but you have to be careful about throwing them off balance. Bioloid already has sensors that come with the kit so it would probably be easier to start building something autonomous with that platform. I have heard the there are going to be several sensors coming out that are made for the robonova. It is really a matter of what you want to do exactly. This is just my $0.02
Good luck with whatever you choose.

Statistics: Posted by sthmck — Mon Nov 19, 2007 4:17 pm