by Bill » Thu Mar 16, 2006 6:24 am
by Bill
Thu Mar 16, 2006 6:24 am
I am an RC Heli pilot as well....
I think the most flexible most fun and most hi tech robot is the boiloid (robotis). Servos just don't cut it with robots (in my opinion). the dynamixel "servos" are extremly useful. As are the hi-tech servos. This is because you get feedback, protection, complience driving, and manage them so well (including cable management). Making sensors will probably be a bit more of a challenge (I would make them addressable), however, the price point of the robotis robots are much better then the robonova and khr-1. The price point of the dynamixel ax-12 is much better then the robonova's HSR-8498HB. the ax-12 is higher torque, weighs the same, higher voltages and offers a lot more documentation then the hi-techs. The plastic gears don't concern me since the ax-12 offers complience driving. Also all settings are done through the seriel bus and dont require a special cable. You can pose the robot and do if/then logic making the quick start easy. People like me can hack in other stuff (my zuarus with a compiler will be first probably).
I have looked at all the robots, downloaded the video's, and read a fair amount of the rants. I tend to think that people just getting into this hobby would be happiest with a kit from robotis. I was suprised to read that the cost was the concern on this list, since I just spent $1000 bucks on a 19 DOF robot (I will be able to turn) robot capable of being a dog, arm, gorilla, dinosaur.... wish I could have purchased from robosavvy since this list has been so helpful. I would have bought a robonova but I didn't want to walk in a streight line
After doing my homework, and reading some man pages, I am happy that I ordered a robotis kit. I have high hopes but I will let yall know.
-=Bill
I am an RC Heli pilot as well....
I think the most flexible most fun and most hi tech robot is the boiloid (robotis). Servos just don't cut it with robots (in my opinion). the dynamixel "servos" are extremly useful. As are the hi-tech servos. This is because you get feedback, protection, complience driving, and manage them so well (including cable management). Making sensors will probably be a bit more of a challenge (I would make them addressable), however, the price point of the robotis robots are much better then the robonova and khr-1. The price point of the dynamixel ax-12 is much better then the robonova's HSR-8498HB. the ax-12 is higher torque, weighs the same, higher voltages and offers a lot more documentation then the hi-techs. The plastic gears don't concern me since the ax-12 offers complience driving. Also all settings are done through the seriel bus and dont require a special cable. You can pose the robot and do if/then logic making the quick start easy. People like me can hack in other stuff (my zuarus with a compiler will be first probably).
I have looked at all the robots, downloaded the video's, and read a fair amount of the rants. I tend to think that people just getting into this hobby would be happiest with a kit from robotis. I was suprised to read that the cost was the concern on this list, since I just spent $1000 bucks on a 19 DOF robot (I will be able to turn) robot capable of being a dog, arm, gorilla, dinosaur.... wish I could have purchased from robosavvy since this list has been so helpful. I would have bought a robonova but I didn't want to walk in a streight line
After doing my homework, and reading some man pages, I am happy that I ordered a robotis kit. I have high hopes but I will let yall know.
-=Bill