by PedroR » Mon Jan 04, 2010 4:35 pm
by PedroR
Mon Jan 04, 2010 4:35 pm
Hi
I noticed you mentioned here
http://vision.eng.shu.ac.uk/mmvlwiki/in ... obobuilder that you have some broken gears and talk about elastic actuators for protecting them.
Indeed, even the RX servos from ROBOTIS (which are all metal gears) experience broken gears when the complaince settings are too tight on the servos.
So the solution to your issue comes in two parts:
1) Yes, you can upgrade to all metal gears and have the improved strength of metal
(while you're at it you may also want to get some Metal Joints
http://robosavvy.com/store/product_info ... cts_id/609 or just keep the plastic joints as the weak link, so that they are the first to break... after all they are cheap and easy to replace)
2) The biggest solution comes from tweaking not only the compliance but specially the PID gains on the servos.
This is something that can't be done on ROBOTIS servos (they don't have PID) but a good tuning of these gains will give you a true, elastic feel to the servos, just like the thesis you were mentioning.
This is done using the wCK Programmer. You will notice that it may be a bit tricky to get the values right (sometimes small adjustments cause huge differences) but getting them right should give you a true elastic feel.
Elasticity is especially important on the shoulders (and maybe knees) but all in all a good elastic setup will help protect your gears.
I tried to send you an email with this information but your WiKi does not have any "Contacts" section...
Regards
Pedro
Hi
I noticed you mentioned here
http://vision.eng.shu.ac.uk/mmvlwiki/in ... obobuilder that you have some broken gears and talk about elastic actuators for protecting them.
Indeed, even the RX servos from ROBOTIS (which are all metal gears) experience broken gears when the complaince settings are too tight on the servos.
So the solution to your issue comes in two parts:
1) Yes, you can upgrade to all metal gears and have the improved strength of metal
(while you're at it you may also want to get some Metal Joints
http://robosavvy.com/store/product_info ... cts_id/609 or just keep the plastic joints as the weak link, so that they are the first to break... after all they are cheap and easy to replace)
2) The biggest solution comes from tweaking not only the compliance but specially the PID gains on the servos.
This is something that can't be done on ROBOTIS servos (they don't have PID) but a good tuning of these gains will give you a true, elastic feel to the servos, just like the thesis you were mentioning.
This is done using the wCK Programmer. You will notice that it may be a bit tricky to get the values right (sometimes small adjustments cause huge differences) but getting them right should give you a true elastic feel.
Elasticity is especially important on the shoulders (and maybe knees) but all in all a good elastic setup will help protect your gears.
I tried to send you an email with this information but your WiKi does not have any "Contacts" section...
Regards
Pedro