by MarcoP » Wed Nov 28, 2012 7:53 pm
by MarcoP
Wed Nov 28, 2012 7:53 pm
Hi
For the main structure of the robot the original plan was to use aluminium.
However we also wanted to evaluate carbon fiber because it's supposed to be stiffer and lighter for the same amount of strength.
So we got a small board (foam cored) and tried to cut it in the cnc:
We were amazed with the quality of the results.
Perfect edges, in the first try. We were expecting the edges to be ragged, but they were smooth.
As comparison it took forever to get aluminium cutting right.
Then on to testing:
We assembled it in a MX106. Just to check the fit. However we were more interested in knowing how much torque we could put on the carbon fiber before it failed.
Not to risk the servo, we tried to screw the carbon fiber to a piece of wood:
We then used a scale normally used to weight luggage to pull the other end of the carbon fiber piece (length about 30 cm). By reading the value in Kg and multiplying it by 30 we get the torque in KgCm.
Just a few Kg were enough to pull the screws from the wood. So carbon fiber 1 - wood 0.
So we moved on to aluminium.
We used 2,5mm metal screws. But not from robotis. general purpose ones.
When we started to pull, this time the screws themselves bended. This uneven force did do slight damage to the screw holes in the carbon fiber.
So we widened the holes to 3mm, and used a nut on the other side.
Still the screws bended a bit which might have accelerated the failure. Still we kept pulling until the carbon fiber failed. This was at about 6Kg, or 180KgCm.
Given the fact that with just two screws, the carbon fiber held to almost twice the rating of the MX106 servos we feel very confident that it will be the best option. In the robot we will have 8 screws to distribute the load, so 4 times less load on each screw, which also should prevent them from bending.
For the more CNC inclided we used a 4 flute 2mm carbide slot drill. From what i have read online it's not a good idea do breathe in carbon fiber dust, however out setup directs all of the air that goes trough the vacuum filter directly outside.
Regards
Marco
Hi
For the main structure of the robot the original plan was to use aluminium.
However we also wanted to evaluate carbon fiber because it's supposed to be stiffer and lighter for the same amount of strength.
So we got a small board (foam cored) and tried to cut it in the cnc:
We were amazed with the quality of the results.
Perfect edges, in the first try. We were expecting the edges to be ragged, but they were smooth.
As comparison it took forever to get aluminium cutting right.
Then on to testing:
We assembled it in a MX106. Just to check the fit. However we were more interested in knowing how much torque we could put on the carbon fiber before it failed.
Not to risk the servo, we tried to screw the carbon fiber to a piece of wood:
We then used a scale normally used to weight luggage to pull the other end of the carbon fiber piece (length about 30 cm). By reading the value in Kg and multiplying it by 30 we get the torque in KgCm.
Just a few Kg were enough to pull the screws from the wood. So carbon fiber 1 - wood 0.
So we moved on to aluminium.
We used 2,5mm metal screws. But not from robotis. general purpose ones.
When we started to pull, this time the screws themselves bended. This uneven force did do slight damage to the screw holes in the carbon fiber.
So we widened the holes to 3mm, and used a nut on the other side.
Still the screws bended a bit which might have accelerated the failure. Still we kept pulling until the carbon fiber failed. This was at about 6Kg, or 180KgCm.
Given the fact that with just two screws, the carbon fiber held to almost twice the rating of the MX106 servos we feel very confident that it will be the best option. In the robot we will have 8 screws to distribute the load, so 4 times less load on each screw, which also should prevent them from bending.
For the more CNC inclided we used a 4 flute 2mm carbide slot drill. From what i have read online it's not a good idea do breathe in carbon fiber dust, however out setup directs all of the air that goes trough the vacuum filter directly outside.
Regards
Marco