by BillB » Mon Jun 29, 2009 3:47 pm
by BillB
Mon Jun 29, 2009 3:47 pm
I have been dabbling with the Bioloid for a number of years and have used many different remote controls.
Bioloid Kit: The Bioloid Kit does not come with any remote control as standard. According to the manual the AX-S1 has an infra red control receiver built-in. But a compatible the IR transmitter has never been made available.
BlueSmirf Hack: The bluesmirf hack works surprisingly well. Using this you can control the Bioloid using a computer that is Bluetooth enabled. This includes Laptops and PDA's. The great advantage of the BlueSmirf Bluetooth this is the range - I have been about 30 metres away with no connectivity problems. I have also rigged up an XBOX3060 controller to a Bluetooth compatible PC and controlled the robot that way. Once again this worked surprisingly well – provided but you need to have a PC up and running (which can be a hassle). The disadvantage is that it can be a bit fiddly to get a Bluetooth connection.
Bioloid Zigbee: Perhaps I have done something wrong I have never had much luck with the Bioloid Zigbee implementation. The connectivity is very poor (you need put the remote very close to the CM5 in order to get a respopnse. The Advantage is that you do not need a PC running to get connection (connection is made automatically), and the Zig100 module is very small and fits very neatly inside the CM-5. The disadvantage is that the poor reception and no Analogue thumbstick control on the Bioloid Boomerang/Banana shaped Controller.
PSX-B - I have been using this for a while now and it is my Bioloid Controller of choice. It works wonderfully well. Advantages: No PC required, Supports Analogue Thumbsticks, and Vibration, good reception range, supports wired controller (useful in noisy competitive environments). Disadvantages: When you combine the size of the PSX-B board and a PS2 wireless receiver it can be about the size of an AX12 servo - so you will need find some extra room on your robot.
Hope this helps.
Bill
I have been dabbling with the Bioloid for a number of years and have used many different remote controls.
Bioloid Kit: The Bioloid Kit does not come with any remote control as standard. According to the manual the AX-S1 has an infra red control receiver built-in. But a compatible the IR transmitter has never been made available.
BlueSmirf Hack: The bluesmirf hack works surprisingly well. Using this you can control the Bioloid using a computer that is Bluetooth enabled. This includes Laptops and PDA's. The great advantage of the BlueSmirf Bluetooth this is the range - I have been about 30 metres away with no connectivity problems. I have also rigged up an XBOX3060 controller to a Bluetooth compatible PC and controlled the robot that way. Once again this worked surprisingly well – provided but you need to have a PC up and running (which can be a hassle). The disadvantage is that it can be a bit fiddly to get a Bluetooth connection.
Bioloid Zigbee: Perhaps I have done something wrong I have never had much luck with the Bioloid Zigbee implementation. The connectivity is very poor (you need put the remote very close to the CM5 in order to get a respopnse. The Advantage is that you do not need a PC running to get connection (connection is made automatically), and the Zig100 module is very small and fits very neatly inside the CM-5. The disadvantage is that the poor reception and no Analogue thumbstick control on the Bioloid Boomerang/Banana shaped Controller.
PSX-B - I have been using this for a while now and it is my Bioloid Controller of choice. It works wonderfully well. Advantages: No PC required, Supports Analogue Thumbsticks, and Vibration, good reception range, supports wired controller (useful in noisy competitive environments). Disadvantages: When you combine the size of the PSX-B board and a PS2 wireless receiver it can be about the size of an AX12 servo - so you will need find some extra room on your robot.
Hope this helps.
Bill