by robogeek3 » Thu Feb 07, 2013 3:56 am
by robogeek3
Thu Feb 07, 2013 3:56 am
Does anyone know if this servo is proper suitable enough for a humanoid robot?
If we compare this servos to the DX-117's sold from Robotis, this is how it pans out:
They have about 9 times the torque, but if you consider the new lengths of arms & legs etc, they have an effective 2-3 times the torque.
They weigh about 12 times what the DX's weigh.
They take up about 12 times the volume of the DX's.
They are about 5 times slower than the DX's.
So realistically, the torque to weight (and torque to size) ratio is shot, as is the speed. These servos would not work on a humanoid of Asimo's size. Furthermore, they have very limited sensing abilities, so walking (realistically) would be out of the question. Of course someone could make a pair of bipedal walking legs - but that has been done many times before.
Harmonic Drive Gears is what I must research next!
It's a tonegawa servo
Does anyone know if this servo is proper suitable enough for a humanoid robot?
If we compare this servos to the DX-117's sold from Robotis, this is how it pans out:
They have about 9 times the torque, but if you consider the new lengths of arms & legs etc, they have an effective 2-3 times the torque.
They weigh about 12 times what the DX's weigh.
They take up about 12 times the volume of the DX's.
They are about 5 times slower than the DX's.
So realistically, the torque to weight (and torque to size) ratio is shot, as is the speed. These servos would not work on a humanoid of Asimo's size. Furthermore, they have very limited sensing abilities, so walking (realistically) would be out of the question. Of course someone could make a pair of bipedal walking legs - but that has been done many times before.
Harmonic Drive Gears is what I must research next!
It's a tonegawa servo
Last edited by robogeek3 on Thu Feb 07, 2013 7:52 am, edited 1 time in total.